• Brachers
  • Home
  • Insights
  • Our People
  • Careers
  • About Brachers
    • Our Story
    • Awards and Accreditations
    • Corporate Social Responsibility
  • Events
  • Pay online
  • Conveyancing quote
  • Contact us
    • Solicitors in Maidstone
    • Solicitors in Canterbury
    • Debt Payment
  • Personal Law
    • Personal Law
    • Court of Protection
    • Dispute Resolution
    • Employment Law Advice
    • Family and Divorce
    • Personal Injury and Industrial Disease
    • Powers of Attorney
    • Property and Conveyancing
    • Tax Planning
    • Trusts
    • Wills and Probate
  • Business Law
    • Business Law
    • Commercial Law
    • Commercial Dispute Resolution
    • Commercial Property Law
    • Corporate, Banking and Finance
    • Debt Recovery
    • Defending Industrial Disease Claims
    • Employment Lawyers & HR Support
    • Environmental Law
    • Family Business Solicitors
    • Insolvency
    • Licensing Law
    • Planning Law
    • Private Wealth
    • Regulatory Law
  • Sector Support
    • Sector Support
    • Agriculture and Rural
    • Charity Solicitors
    • Construction
    • Education
    • Healthcare
    • Life Sciences
    • Primary Care
    • Property Managers, Investors and Landlords
    • Energy, waste and sustainability industry
    • 01622 690691
    • Conveyancing Quote
    • Pay Online
    Brachers
  • Brachers
    • Insights
    • Our People
    • Careers
    • About Brachers
      • Our Story
      • Awards and Accreditations
      • Corporate Social Responsibility
      • Health and Wellbeing of Visiting Clients
    • Events
    • Contact Us
      • Maidstone office
      • Canterbury office
      • Debt Payment
    •  
  • Personal Law
  • Business Law
  • Sector Support
  • Court of Protection
    • Court of Protection
    • Benefits Advice for Financial Attorneys and Deputies
    • Financial Deputy Applications Advice
    • Gifting Applications
    • Professional Financial Attorney and Deputy
    • Statutory Will Applications
    • Welfare Applications
  • Dispute Resolution
    • Dispute Resolution
    • Alternative Dispute Resolution ‘ADR’
    • Consumer Disputes
    • Landlord and Tenant Disputes
    • Professional Negligence Disputes
    • Property & Land Law Disputes
    • Wills, Trusts and Probate Disputes Solicitors
  • Employment Law Advice
    • Employment Law Advice
    • Director Disputes
    • Disciplinary, Capability, Sickness and Grievance Issues
    • Settlement Agreements
    • Tribunal Claims Advice and Representation
  • Family and Divorce
    • Family and Divorce
    • Children Law
    • Civil Partnership
    • Divorce
    • Injunctions
    • Cohabitation
    • Mediation
    • Pre and Post Nuptial Agreement
  • Family Business Solicitors
  • Personal Injury and Industrial Disease
    • Personal Injury and Industrial Disease
    • Asbestos Disease
    • Fatal Accident Claims
    • Head Injury
    • Mesothelioma Claims
    • Other Industrial Disease Claims
    • Other Personal Injury Claims
    • Post Traumatic Stress Disorder/Psychiatric Injury Claims
  • Powers of Attorney
    • Powers of Attorney Solicitors
    • Elderly and Vulnerable Solicitors
  • Private Wealth Solicitors
  • Property and Conveyancing
    • Property and Conveyancing
    • Equity Release
    • Lease Extensions
    • Joint Tenancy or Tenancy in Common
  • Tax Planning
  • Trusts
    • Trusts
    • Brachers Trust Corporation
    • Setting up a Trust
    • Trust Management Services
  • Wills and Probate
    • Wills and Probate
    • Probate and Estate Administration Solicitors
    • Wills
    • Wills, Trusts and Probate Disputes Solicitors
  • Commercial Law
    • Commercial Law
    • Commercial Agreements
    • Commercial Projects
    • Information Technology
    • Intellectual Property (IP)
  • Commercial Dispute Resolution
    • Commercial Dispute Resolution
    • Alternative Dispute Resolution ‘ADR’ for Business
    • Business to Business Disputes
    • Contract Disputes
    • Corporate Disputes
    • Intellectual Property and Technology Disputes
    • Partnership Disputes
    • Property and Land Disputes
  • Commercial Property Law
    • Commercial Property Law
    • Finance Advice for Commercial Property
    • Occupiers and Tenants
    • Property Managers, Investors and Landlords
    • Property Developers
  • Corporate, Banking and Finance
    • Corporate, Banking and Finance
    • Shareholder Arrangements and Share Option Schemes Advice
    • Corporate Banking Law and Asset-Based Lending
    • Corporate Restructures and Demergers
    • Legal Advice for Joint Venture Companies
    • Mergers, Acquisitions and Disposals
    • Partnership and LLP
    • Private Equity and Venture Finance
  • Data Protection and GDPR
  • Debt Recovery
  • Defending Industrial Disease Claims
    • Defending Industrial Disease Claims
    • Defending Asbestos Claims
    • Defending Hearing Loss / Deafness Claims
  • Employment Lawyers & HR Support
    • Employment Lawyers & HR Support
    • Brachers Connect
    • Brachers Protect
    • Discrimination, Discipline, Dismissals & Grievances
    • Employee Exits and Settlement Agreements Law
    • Employment Tribunal Solicitors
    • Redundancy, Reorganisation & Restructuring Law
    • Restrictive Covenants Solicitors
    • TUPE Law
    • Wellbeing at Work Law
  • Environmental Law
  • Family Business Solicitors
  • Insolvency
    • Insolvency
    • Services to Businesses & Company Directors
    • Services to Creditors
    • Services to Insolvency Practitioners
  • Licensing Law
  • Planning Law
  • Regulatory Law
    • Regulatory Law
    • Criminal Prosecution Law
  • Agriculture and Rural
    • Agriculture and Rural
    • Commercial Law in Rural Business
    • Corporate Law in Rural Business
    • Employment Law in Rural Business
    • Family Law in Rural Business
    • Health and Safety Law in Rural Business
    • Planning & Environmental Law
    • Rural Property and Buildings Law
    • Secured Lending in Rural Business
    • Solving Disputes in Rural Business
    • Succession Planning for Farming Businesses
  • Charities
  • Construction
    • Construction
    • Construction Disputes
    • Construction Project Documentation
  • Education
    • Education
    • Academy conversions and free schools
    • Development and Expansion
    • Education Matters Forum
    • Freedom of Information and Data Protection
    • Governance, Complaints and Appeals Law in Education
    • Legal Advice when Purchasing Goods and Services for Schools
    • Legal Advice for School Premises
    • Legal Advice for Staff Management
  • Energy, waste and sustainability industry
    • Energy, waste and sustainability industry
    • Energy lawyers
    • Waste-to-energy and energy recovery
  • Healthcare
    • Healthcare
    • Independent Healthcare Providers
    • Legal Support for Care Providers
  • Life Sciences
  • Primary Care
    • Primary Care
    • Commercial and NHS Contracts
    • Employment & HR Law for GPs
    • GP Federations Advice
    • GP Partnership Agreements
    • New Premises, Development & Expansion
  • Real Estate
    • Property Managers, Investors and Landlords
    • Property Developers

Home > Insights > Leasing of land: Get your affairs in order to avoid a legal quagmire

  • Insights
    Insight - Agriculture and Rural - POSTED: April 4 2018

    Leasing of land: Get your affairs in order to avoid a legal quagmire

    When it comes to the leasing of land, matters can get very complex if the parties involved do not put clear agreements in place at the start.

    • Share this article
      Share
    • Print this article
  • The recent High Court case of Smyth-Tyrrell v Bowden [2018] EWHC 106 (Ch) illustrates the perils of what can happen otherwise. The case concerns land which was part of a farm, with the following background history:

    1990’s: there was a derelict house and barn on land which was owned by the Bowden family (the defendants), and the land was overgrown.

    1993 – 2008: the adjoining farmers (the claimants) proposed to the defendants that they take a lease of the land in order to renovate the house, which the claimants intended to use in order to run a holiday letting business. The claimants signed a 15 year lease, but the defendants did not. The claimants then went into occupation and spent money renovating the house. Once the renovations were complete, the claimants granted a sub-tenancy of the house to a company which had been set up by the claimants to run the holiday letting business.

    2008 – 2014: at the end of 15 years, the claimants remained in occupation and carried on paying the rent. There were various discussions between the claimants and the defendants about the land, including discussions about the claimants buying the land.  However, no sale was ever concluded.

    2014: the defendants served Notices to Quit on the claimants, requiring them to vacate the land by the end of 2014.

    2015: the claimants issued proceedings, asking the court to show that the claimants were entitled to remain in occupation of the land.

    2017 – 2018: the trial took place and the claimants lost.

    The claimants tried to persuade the court that they should remain in occupation of the land by relying on three different and ultimately unsuccessful grounds:

    Agricultural Holdings Act 1986 tenancy

    The claimants argued that they had a tenancy under the AHA 1986, based on the fact that the land was agricultural land, and they had gone into occupation of the land and paid rent. This ground failed because the court found that the land was in fact unfarmable, and that the 1993 letting had not been for the purpose of carrying out an agricultural activity, but rather for the purposes of tourism.

    Landlord & Tenant Act 1954 business tenancy

    The claimants said that they had a right to a new tenancy under the 1954 Act, this being an automatic right to renew a tenancy, which many business tenants have. However, the claim under this ground failed owing to very technical arguments on the interpretation of various provisions in the 1954 Act.

    The Doctrine of Promissory estoppel

    This doctrine provides that where a promise is made to a party, and that party acts on the promise to their detriment, then the person who made the promise is “estopped” or prevented from going back on that promise.  However, reliance on this doctrine can, as the claimants found out, be problematical where there is no actual promise which is made, but where one party simply lets a state of affairs continue. The defendants never actually promised the claimants that they could remain in occupation of the land indefinitely if they renovated the house.

    If the claimants had put their affairs in order, and a clear agreement had been entered into with the defendants at the start, then this unsuccessful outcome could have been avoided – namely:

    • the claimants could have renovated the house knowing that they would be able to run the holiday let business from it for as long as they wanted to
    • the claimants would not have lost their investment in renovating the house
    • everyone involved would not have suffered years of uncertainty and stress, fighting complex, lengthy and costly legal proceedings.

    The case is a sobering reminder of the need to sort out matters clearly at the outset, and as soon as an arrangement or agreement comes to an end. If not, you risk facing years of uncertainty and getting bogged down in a complex legal quagmire.

    Before entering into an agreement such as a lease of land, you should seek legal advice to ensure that you are protected in the event of any future dispute.

    This article first appeared in the April 2018 edition of South East Farmer magazine. 

    This content is correct at time of publication

    Can we help?

    Take a look at our Agriculture and Rural page for useful information, resources, guidance, details of our team and how we may be able to help you

  • Key contact:

    • Brachers Commercial Litigation Partner Allis Beasley

      Allis Beasley

      Partner,

    Get in touch

    Please fill out the below form or alternatively you can call us on 01622 690691

      By submitting an enquiry through 'get in touch' your data will only be used to contact you regarding your enquiry. Please view our privacy statement for more information
  • Related Articles & Events

    View all
  • Property and Conveyancing

    What rights do I have to get my rental property repaired?

    Insight

    Posted 10th February 2020

  • Agriculture and Rural

    The risk of investing in farmland

    Insight

    Posted 9th January 2015

  • Agriculture and Rural

    Sewing the seeds for success

    Insight

    Posted 5th November 2014

  • Brachers with you all the way Logo
    • Statutory Information (including complaints policy)
    • Cookie Policy
    • Refund Policy
    • Privacy Statement
    • Terms of Engagement
    • Website Accessibility
    • Contact Us
    • Sitemap
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy
    • Payments & Refund Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Statutory Information
  • Contact Us

    T: 01622 690691
    T: 01622 767484
    F: 01622 681430
    E: hello@brachers.co.uk
    E: bcr@brachers.co.uk
    • LinkedIn Icon
    • Facebook Icon
    • Twitter Icon

    Sign up for our newsletter

    Unsubscribe from our newsletter

    SIGN UP
  • Head Office

    Somerfield House
    59 London Road
    Maidstone
    Kent
    ME16 8JH


    T: 01622 690691

  • Medway House

    81 London Road
    Maidstone
    Kent
    ME16 0DU

     

     


    T: 01622 690691

  • Canterbury Office

    First Floor
    Graylaw House
    20-22 Watling Street
    Canterbury
    Kent
    CT1 2UA


    T: 01227 949510