-
InsightsInsight - Family and Divorce - POSTED: November 7 2019
Judge rules mental capacity to marry but not over own finances
The Court of Protection for England and Wales has granted permission to a man to marry his fiancée, even though there were questions surrounding his mental capacity and an objection made.
- Share this article
- Print this article
-
-
The 28-year-old man does not have the mental capacity to manage his financial affairs and because of this, has a financial deputy in place to manage them on his behalf. The man has also had learning difficulties since childhood.
Legal professionals have long been concerned that the barometer for judging mental capacity to make a Will is more stringent than the test for who is fit to marry. While many may believe that it’s not a court’s place to decide who can marry, marriage automatically revokes a pre-existing Will unless made specifically in contemplation of the marriage and can therefore fundamentally change the entitlements to an estate after death.
This recent case which was heard in September 2019 shows us that the courts are now leaning in favour of an individual’s rights to marry, regardless of mental capacity over their own finances. It was brought about by the man’s financial deputy who manages an estate worth around £1.5 million on behalf of the man.
He raised concerns after the man announced he intended to marry his fiancée, who he met three years ago and now lives with, along with her two children. The man’s financial deputy challenged his intentions on the basis that the individual does not have the mental capacity to consent to marriage.
The financial deputy raised concerns that the individual is easily persuaded, is very vulnerable and has difficulties saying no. The financial deputy also had concerns about the financial implications insofar that the individual would not be able to understand all of the implications of marriage, due to his lack of mental capacity, more importantly, understanding the implications of if they were to divorce, then the wife could have a financial remedy claim against his estate.
Judge Mostyn from the Court of Protection disagreed with the prevention application by the financial deputy and stated that the individual had previously been confirmed as having mental capacity to prepare a Will, leaving everything to his parents and that the threshold to consent to marriage, is likely to be lower than the mental capacity threshold to understand and execute a Will.
Judge Mostyn also noted that people can have capacity to marry without the need to understand how a financial remedy law claim works.
In conclusion to the case, Judge Mostyn dismissed the financial deputy’s application to prevent the marriage and subsequently granted the individual permission to marry his fiancée. However, Judge Mostyn did suggest that the individual prepare and execute a codicil to his current Will, legally stating that his marriage does not invalidate his current Will.
While a unique situation, this case can be used as a benchmark for others questioning the different tests used to establish mental capacity to consent to marriage.
At Brachers we have a specialist Court of Protection team dealing with capacity issues so if you have any questions, please contact us.
Can we help?
Take a look at our Family and Divorce page for useful information, resources, guidance, details of our team and how we may be able to help you
-
Key contact:
Get in touch
Please fill out the below form or alternatively you can call us on 01622 690691
-
Related Articles & Events
View all
-
Family and Divorce
Coronavirus self-isolation linked to big increase in domestic violence
News
Posted 31st March 2020
-
Family and Divorce
Guidance on child arrangements and coronavirus
Insight
Posted 25th March 2020
-
Family and Divorce
Divorce in 2020: reform progress and Brachers’ fixed fee divorce services
Insight
Posted 15th January 2020
-
Family and Divorce
Brachers offers fixed fee divorce ahead of Divorce Day on 6 January
News
Posted 6th January 2020
-
Family and Divorce
Cohabitation: the common law marriage myth
Insight
Posted 23rd December 2019
-
Family and Divorce
Judge rules mental capacity to marry but not over own finances
Insight
Posted 7th November 2019
-
Family and Divorce
When the wife becomes a widow
Insight
Posted 15th October 2019
-
Brachers
Brachers shortlisted for top accolade at Family Law Awards
News
Posted 9th September 2019
-
Family and Divorce
Review calls for changes to special guardianship orders (SGOs)
Insight
Posted 6th September 2019
-
Family and Divorce
How to seek protection from domestic abuse
Insight
Posted 29th July 2019
-
Family and Divorce
Civil partnerships to be extended for heterosexual couples
Insight
Posted 26th July 2019
-
Family and Divorce
Court approves service by WhatsApp in cross-border family dispute
Insight
Posted 4th July 2019
-
Family and Divorce
Will a recent judgment published the door to more welfare deputyships?
Insight
Posted 28th June 2019
-
Family and Divorce
Why a pre-nuptial agreement?
Insight
Posted 27th June 2019
-
Family and Divorce
Personal Independence Payment – Appealing a Decision
Insight
Posted 26th June 2019
-
Family and Divorce
Changes to divorce law to end the blame game
Insight
Posted 9th April 2019
-
Family and Divorce
Is arbitration the future when resolving family disputes?
Insight
Posted 8th April 2019
-
Family and Divorce
Higher Divorce Settlements in England vs Italy? Have your Cake and Eat it
Insight
Posted 4th April 2019
-
Family and Divorce
CAFCASS guidance published on parental alienation
Insight
Posted 28th March 2019
-
Family and Divorce
A pub promise
Insight
Posted 25th March 2019
-
Family and Divorce
Brachers Family Partner contributes to comprehensive new guide for separating parents
News
Posted 13th March 2019
-
Family and Divorce
Could the Forfeiture Act stop you from inheriting?
Insight
Posted 27th February 2019
-
Family and Divorce
Carer’s Allowance
Insight
Posted 18th February 2019
-
Family and Divorce
New Year, New Beginnings
Insight
Posted 24th January 2019
-
Family and Divorce
Changes to Pension Credit
Insight
Posted 18th January 2019
-
Family and Divorce
The future of farming: keeping divorce out of the courts
Insight
Posted 15th January 2019
-
Family and Divorce
Child arrangements at Christmas
Insight
Posted 13th December 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Pitfalls of using online divorce petition
Insight
Posted 7th December 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Good Divorce Week
Insight
Posted 26th November 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Benefit entitlements for disabled people – Attendance Allowance
Insight
Posted 12th November 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Tax warning for separating spouses
Insight
Posted 9th November 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Our Personal Affairs team in action
Client Story
Posted 30th October 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Access to family courts has been granted to legal bloggers
Insight
Posted 19th October 2018
-
Family and Divorce
The importance of parental responsibility for grandparents
Insight
Posted 12th October 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Prime Minister announces change to law for mixed-sex couples
Insight
Posted 3rd October 2018
-
Court of Protection
Son given authority to gift himself £6 million by Court of Protection
Insight
Posted 14th September 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Private client solicitor shortlisted for international accolade at prestigious awards
News
Posted 9th August 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Mills v Mills – Supreme Court ruling against an increase of spousal maintenance
Insight
Posted 2nd August 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Cohabitation – the fastest growing family type in the UK
Insight
Posted 1st August 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Owens v Owens highlights the need to reform divorce law
Insight
Posted 25th July 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Divorce in farming families
Insight
Posted 13th July 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Brachers ranked as leading provider in Top Family Law Firm rankings
News
Posted 11th July 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Charity suspects persistent misuse of Non-molestation Orders
Insight
Posted 5th July 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Opposite-sex couple win legal battle on civil partnership case
Insight
Posted 29th June 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Exploring the benefits of trusts in divorce
Insight
Posted 28th June 2018
-
Family and Divorce
The growing use of arbitration in family law
Insight
Posted 26th June 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Benefit entitlements for disabled people – Personal Independence Payments
Insight
Posted 22nd June 2018
-
Family and Divorce
When ‘I do’ becomes ‘I don’t’ – Protecting your assets pre and post nuptials
Insight
Posted 13th June 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Debating the issue of contact for grandparents
Insight
Posted 10th May 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Continuing need for change in law regarding bereavement damages for couples living together
Insight
Posted 19th April 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Specialist financial remedy courts
Insight
Posted 13th April 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Government considers implementing changes to civil partnerships
Insight
Posted 7th March 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Does conduct play a part in the financial proceedings on divorce?
Insight
Posted 5th March 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Billionaire challenges divorce settlement
Insight
Posted 19th February 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Non-molestation orders and occupation orders
Insight
Posted 26th January 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Divorce Day – what is it?
Insight
Posted 8th January 2018
-
Family and Divorce
Recovery of child maintenance arrears – are the changes sufficient?
Insight
Posted 13th November 2017
-
Family and Divorce
Covert recording in child proceedings
Insight
Posted 6th November 2017
-
Family and Divorce
Divorce statistics 2017
Insight
Posted 23rd October 2017
-
Family and Divorce
Zimina v Zimin –second chance in overseas divorce?
Insight
Posted 18th October 2017
-
Family and Divorce
The Bach Commission – a family perspective
Insight
Posted 9th October 2017
-
Family and Divorce
Divorce petition changes
Insight
Posted 7th September 2017
-
Family and Divorce
Birch v. Birch
Insight
Posted 1st August 2017
-
Family and Divorce
Financial proceedings arising from divorce or civil partnership dissolution
Insight
Posted 14th July 2017
-
Family and Divorce
Marry me, my farm and my pre-nup?
Insight
Posted 5th July 2017
-
Family and Divorce
Court of Appeal reduces husband’s divorce pay out in short marriage
Insight
Posted 14th June 2017
-
Family and Divorce
UK’s biggest ever divorce settlement
Insight
Posted 16th May 2017
-
Family and Divorce
Effective child maintenance payments
Client Story
Posted 2nd March 2017
-
Family and Divorce
What Brexit means for divorce
Insight
Posted 23rd February 2017
-
Family and Divorce
Defended Divorce is it ‘Just?’
Client Story
Posted 15th February 2017
-
Family and Divorce
Saying “I Do” to a prenuptial agreement
Insight
Posted 9th December 2016
-
Family and Divorce
No Fault Divorce, should the law be reformed?
Insight
Posted 1st December 2016
-
Family and Divorce
Resolution speaks out about the law on cohabitation
Insight
Posted 14th November 2016
-
Family and Divorce
Why are prenuptial agreements binding on the continent and not here?
Insight
Posted 24th August 2016
-
Family and Divorce
Arbitration extended to include disputes about children
Insight
Posted 1st August 2016
-
Family and Divorce
Cohabitation – case report
Insight
Posted 22nd July 2016
-
Family and Divorce
Ex-model’s divorce settlement based on actual needs
Insight
Posted 14th July 2016
-
Family and Divorce
What is Family Mediation?
Insight
Posted 22nd June 2016
-
Family and Divorce
Family breakdown. Why Collaborate?
Insight
Posted 9th June 2016
-
Family and Divorce
One in five couples in ‘distressed’ relationships
Insight
Posted 26th May 2016
-
Family and Divorce
No sharing of shared parental leave
Insight
Posted 5th April 2016
-
Family and Divorce
Divorce and Commercial Litigation – an uncertain mix
Insight
Posted 20th October 2015
-
Family and Divorce
Government announces plan to extend shared parental leave to include grandparents
Insight
Posted 7th October 2015
-
Family and Divorce
Transferable ISAs and the complexities that surrounds them
Insight
Posted 14th September 2015
-
Family and Divorce
Coroners’ Courts 2015 – Can the family recover their costs?
Insight
Posted 11th August 2015
-
Family and Divorce
Coroners’ Courts 2015 – Family funding rules to be relaxed
Insight
Posted 11th August 2015
-
Family and Divorce
Restrictions on disinheriting children
Insight
Posted 28th July 2015
-
Family and Divorce
Child Safety Week 1-7 June 2015 – Preventing avoidable accidents to children
Insight
Posted 26th May 2015
-
Family and Divorce
Research reveals one in five couples are planning to start divorce proceedings in January 2015
Client Story
Posted 14th January 2015
-
Family and Divorce
When it comes to divorce, does age matter?
Client Story
Posted 6th January 2015
-
Family and Divorce
Non-payment of Child Maintenance to damage credit rating
News
Posted 17th November 2014
-
Family and Divorce
Parental involvement provision comes into force
Insight
Posted 23rd October 2014
-
Family and Divorce
We want to be together – parents to have more family time following birth?
Insight
Posted 6th January 2014
-
Court of Protection
Why the Court of Protection may not grant permission for a health and welfare deputy order
Insight
Posted 18th April 2012
-
Family and Divorce
What rights do grandparents have for financial assistance when caring for grandchildren?
Insight
Posted 7th December 2011